Your mortgage renewal date is approaching, and your lender has sent you an offer.
The easiest option may seem obvious: sign the renewal and move on.
But is that actually the best financial decision?
For many Ontario homeowners, mortgage renewal is an opportunity to reassess their interest rate, mortgage term, payment options and future financial plans.
You are not required to renew your mortgage with your current lender. You may be able to switch to another lender if you find a mortgage product that better suits your needs.
So, should you renew with your current lender or switch?
Here are 5 important things Ontario homeowners should consider before signing their next mortgage term.
1. Don’t Automatically Accept Your First Renewal Offer
Your renewal letter should be treated as a starting point—not necessarily your final mortgage decision.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada recommends shopping around before renewing and comparing offers from different lenders and mortgage professionals. You may also be able to negotiate with your existing lender for a better rate or different terms.
The advantage of renewing with your current lender:
✔ Less paperwork
✔ Usually a simpler process
✔ You may avoid applying with a completely new lender
✔ Your lender already has your mortgage history
The potential downside:
⚠ You may not receive the most competitive rate automatically
⚠ You may overlook better mortgage features elsewhere
⚠ You could miss an opportunity to improve your overall mortgage strategy
The smart approach: Compare your current lender’s offer with alternatives before making a decision.
A difference of even a fraction of a percentage point can matter—but remember, the lowest rate does not always equal the best mortgage.
Look at the complete package.
2. Compare More Than Just the Interest Rate
When comparing mortgage offers, homeowners often focus entirely on one number:
The interest rate.
But your mortgage contract includes much more.
Before renewing or switching, compare:
- Interest rate
- Mortgage term
- Monthly payment
- Amortization period
- Prepayment privileges
- Lump-sum payment options
- Payment flexibility
- Portability if you plan to move
- Penalties if you break the mortgage early
- Fees and costs associated with switching
Ontario’s Financial Services Regulatory Authority advises borrowers to understand the costs, penalties and features included in their mortgage contract, including administration fees and portability provisions.
Example:
Imagine Lender A offers a slightly lower rate but has restrictive prepayment options and potentially expensive penalties.
Lender B may offer a slightly higher rate but better flexibility if you expect to sell, move or refinance.
Depending on your plans, Lender B could actually be the better choice.
3. Switching Lenders Could Save Money—But There May Be Costs
One major advantage of switching at the end of your mortgage term is that you generally avoid the prepayment penalty that could apply if you break your mortgage in the middle of the term.
However, switching lenders does not necessarily mean the process is free.
Depending on your mortgage and lender, potential costs may include:
- Mortgage discharge or administrative fees
- Registration or assignment costs
- Legal fees
- Appraisal fees
- Other lender or administrative charges
We recommends asking your new lender whether they are willing to cover some or all of the costs of switching.
Switching: Pros
✔ Potentially access a better rate
✔ Find better mortgage features
✔ Improve prepayment flexibility
✔ Choose a mortgage better suited to your current financial situation
Switching: Cons
⚠ You will generally need approval from the new lender
⚠ There may be legal, appraisal, registration or administrative costs
⚠ The process requires more paperwork and planning
⚠ Some mortgage registrations, including collateral charges, can make switching more complicated or expensive
The key question is:
Will the total savings and benefits of switching outweigh the costs and effort involved?
4. Your Financial Situation Has Changed Since You First Got Your Mortgage
A mortgage that was perfect five years ago may no longer fit your life today.
Maybe:
- Your income has increased—or decreased
- You have new debts
- You are planning to move
- You want to make larger lump-sum payments
- You want to pay off your mortgage faster
- You need to lower your monthly payments
- You are considering renovations or accessing home equity
Mortgage renewal is an opportunity to review whether your current product still works for your financial goals.
However, be careful about simply extending your amortization to reduce your monthly payment. While this may improve short-term cash flow, it can also increase the total interest you pay over time.
A mortgage renewal should be a financial review, not just a signature on another five-year contract.
5. Start Planning Before Your Renewal Date
One of the biggest mistakes homeowners make is waiting until the last minute.
The FCAC recommends beginning your mortgage search a few months before your term ends. This gives you time to compare lenders, negotiate and understand the costs and conditions of switching.
Many lenders and mortgage professionals also allow borrowers to begin the renewal process well before the maturity date.
Starting early gives you time to:
✔ Compare multiple mortgage options
✔ Negotiate with your existing lender
✔ Apply to a new lender if appropriate
✔ Complete legal and registration requirements
✔ Understand your potential new payment
✔ Avoid making a rushed decision
If you are considering switching, remember that the new lender will generally need to approve your mortgage application.
The lender may use different approval criteria from those used when you originally obtained your mortgage.
Renew or Switch? A Quick Comparison
| Renew With Current Lender | Switch to Another Lender |
| Usually simpler | May require more paperwork |
| Often faster | New lender approval is generally required |
| May have fewer immediate costs | Legal and administrative costs may apply |
| Easy if you are happy with your mortgage | Opportunity to compare rates and features |
| May be ideal for convenience | May offer better value or flexibility |
So, Should You Renew or Switch Your Mortgage?
There is no single answer for every Ontario homeowner.
Renewing may make sense if:
- Your lender offers a competitive rate
- You are happy with your mortgage features
- The cost of switching outweighs the potential savings
- You want a simple and straightforward renewal
- Your current mortgage fits your future plans
Switching may make sense if:
- Another lender offers better overall terms
- You can save enough to justify any switching costs
- You want better prepayment privileges
- You need more flexibility
- You are unhappy with your current lender or mortgage features
The Bottom Line
Don’t automatically renew your mortgage just because your current lender sent you an offer.
Mortgage renewal is one of the best opportunities to review your finances and make sure your mortgage still works for your goals.
Compare rates. Compare terms. Understand the fees. Look at flexibility. And most importantly, consider what you expect your life and finances to look like over the next few years.
The best mortgage renewal decision is not always about finding the lowest advertised rate.
It’s about finding a mortgage that works for your budget, your home and your future plans.
Is Your Mortgage Renewal Coming Up?
If you’re a homeowner in Ontario and your mortgage is coming up for renewal, now may be the right time to review your options before automatically signing another term.
Planning to buy, sell, invest, or make a move in the next few years? Your mortgage choice can affect your real estate strategy.
Contact Jimmy Singh, Mortgage Agent at MyMortgageShop.ca , for straightforward real estate guidance and help connecting with qualified mortgage professionals and legal advisors who can help you understand your options.
Before you renew, know your options. Before you switch, understand the total cost. And before you sign, make sure your mortgage fits your future plans.
This article is provided for general educational purposes only and does not constitute mortgage, financial, legal or tax advice. Mortgage rates, qualification requirements, lender policies, fees and legal requirements can vary.